I fell in love with Carrabba’s Caesar salad from the first time I tried it. Luckily, the owners of the restaurant published a cookbook with the recipe:
Ciao Y’All by Damian Mandola and Johnny Carrabba
If you want the exact recipe, I’d advise you to get the book or check it out from the library. I tried the recipe, but even with perfection, I had to have my own additions/subtractions, tweaking here and there until the dressing I made was distinctly my own. That said, I certainly do recommended the recipe in the cookbook!
One other note: I keep getting searches by people who want to make caesar dressing without anchovies–try anchovy paste and/or worcestershire sauce as a substitute, but keep in mind anchovy is the heart of caesar salad dressing.
Here’s my version of Caesar Salad Dressing:
Open and drain 1 can (2 oz) of anchovies. Place the anchovies in plain water. This removes some of the salt and since the oil in the anchovies is permeated with the fish, it also keeps the anchovies from being too strong in the recipe.
Soak the anchovies for five to ten minutes and drain the water and oil off.
Mince four medium to large cloves of garlic and put in bottom of blender with 2 tablespoons of olive oil
Blend on low speed (you won’t get much blending at this stage).
Add to blender:
1 scant tablespoons capers
8-10 anchovies (1 can) –or 1 1/2 tablespoons anchovy paste
Blend on low speed until completely mixed.
Add:
1 and 1/2 tsp dry mustard
2 tsp sugar
Blend again on low speed.
Add:
3 egg yolks with a little of the egg whites (or two very large eggs)
Blend on low speed until everything is creamy and well-mixed.
After everything has mixed well, continue blending on slowest speed and drizzle slowly into the blender:
1 1/4 cups olive oil.
Adding it slowly allows the mixture to “cream.”
When everything is well blended:
Add 8-9 tablespoons red wine vinegar
1/4 tsp to 1/2 tsp Tabasco sauce
juice from 1/2 medium lemon
Blend
Add 1/2 to 3/4 cup grated (not packed) romano or asiago cheese and blend again.
For the salad, tear romaine lettuce and slice fresh mushrooms. Toss. Use about 2 tablespoons of the salad dressing per salad serving. Serve with extra romano, parmesan or asiago cheese on top!